Menu

15 Best Auto Insurance Brokerages in Orlando

Choosing an auto insurance brokerage in Orlando is easier when the search begins with your actual driving situation. The right conversation may involve standard car coverage, a Florida move, motorcycle insurance, an SR-22 policy, or a commercial vehicle.

Before requesting a quote, gather driver and vehicle details and explain any coverage gaps you are worried about. It is also useful to confirm language support, documentation requirements, and whether home, auto, or commercial policies can be discussed together.

How we built this ranking

Our ranking of auto insurance brokerages in Orlando is editorial. It combines public reputation, how focused each business is on this service and the information it gives about its work.

No business can pay to be included. Those already in the guide may buy extra visibility, and it is always shown.

Top 3The full listMapPicking the right one

Compare 15 options nearby

Univista Insurance, Orlando#1
Strong points
  • Patient policy guidance

  • Commercial vehicle support

Univista Insurance

5.02,739 reviews
7217 E Colonial Dr Suite 112, Orlando, FL 32807, United States
Ideal for
Drivers comparing auto coverage

Univista Insurance is an Orlando auto insurance agency built around patient guidance and clear policy explanations. The team takes time to answer questions, compare options, and help drivers find coverage aligned with their needs and budget.

Its friendly, efficient service also extends to commercial vehicle policies, with careful follow-through from quote to paperwork. On-site assistance makes it a useful stop for drivers who prefer personal support while reviewing their insurance options.

Univista Insurance, Orlando#2
Strong points
  • New-to-Florida guidance

  • Careful quote support

Univista Insurance

4.92,281 reviews
637 S Semoran Blvd Suite C-D, Orlando, FL 32807, United States
Ideal for
Drivers new to Florida

Univista Insurance helps Orlando drivers compare auto insurance options with patient, personal guidance. Its team explains coverage clearly, works through quotes carefully, and keeps the process manageable for people who are new to Florida or reviewing an existing policy.

The agency also assists with renewals and related insurance needs, combining friendly communication with efficient follow-through. On-site service suits drivers who want to sit down with an agent and understand their choices before selecting coverage.

Erb and Young Insurance, Orlando#3
Strong points
  • Personalized independent advice

Erb and Young Insurance

4.91,107 reviews
7575 Dr Phillips Blvd #240, Orlando, FL 32819, United States

Erb and Young Insurance is an independent Orlando agency offering auto, home, flood, boat, and small business insurance. Its service model is deliberately personal: agents take time to understand individual circumstances, explain policy details in plain language, and present coverage suited to the situation.

That thoughtful approach is useful for customers facing major changes, renewals, or more involved insurance questions. The agency also works with professional service providers, offering specialized guidance where standard business coverage may not address professional liability concerns.

White Agency, Inc, Orlando#4
Strong points
  • Personalized guidance across policy lines

White Agency, Inc

5.0136 reviews
12954 Tanja King Blvd, Orlando, FL 32828, United States
Ideal for
Home and auto bundlesCommercial insurance

The White Agency is an independent Orlando insurance agency serving East Orlando with auto, home, life, business and umbrella coverage. Established local experience supports a consultative approach: agents take time to explain policy language, identify potential gaps and build coverage around the customer’s actual household or business needs.

The agency is particularly strong for customers coordinating several policies, including home-and-auto bundles or commercial insurance. Service is organized and proactive, with clear communication and quick quotes delivered through a local team rather than a purely transactional call-center process.

GoldenTrust Insurance Central Florida, Orlando#5
Strong points
  • Commercial auto guidance for service businesses

  • Clear multi-policy support

GoldenTrust Insurance Central Florida

5.0128 reviews
7680 Universal Blvd Ste 200, Orlando, FL 32819, United States
Ideal for
Commercial vehicle coverageAuto and home insurance

GoldenTrust Insurance Central Florida helps Orlando customers arrange auto, home, health and commercial coverage with a clear, efficient process. The team is especially useful for business owners needing commercial auto insurance, including coverage for service trucks and residential-service operations.

Agents explain available options, answer questions promptly and work to match protection with the customer’s budget. Online appointments and on-site service are available, while advance scheduling is required. The agency’s practical strength is handling several policy needs without making the process feel fragmented.

Direct Auto Insurance, Orlando#6
Strong points
  • Patient one-to-one coverage guidance

Direct Auto Insurance

4.9333 reviews
5231 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32807, United States
Ideal for
Drivers comparing coverage options

Direct Auto Insurance serves Orlando drivers with auto insurance guidance focused on clear options, patient explanations and an efficient quoting process. The service is especially approachable for people who want to understand coverage choices before making a decision rather than simply receiving a price.

Appointments can be handled online, while on-site service is also available. The agency’s strongest differentiator is attentive one-to-one assistance, with questions answered directly and policy details explained in straightforward terms.

Acceptance Insurance, Orlando#7
Strong points
  • Bilingual help across several policy types

Acceptance Insurance

4.9268 reviews
4434 Hoffner Ave A8, Orlando, FL 32812, United States
Ideal for
Auto and motorcycle coverage

Acceptance Insurance in Orlando helps compare auto, renters, motorcycle and home insurance, with agents who explain choices clearly and keep the process moving. The office is geared toward practical policy shopping, including customers looking for affordable coverage, multiple-policy options or assistance after an administrative insurance problem.

Service is available on site, and the agency provides bilingual assistance. The team’s strongest appeal is the combination of efficient renewals, patient answers and active help finding an option that fits the customer’s needs rather than leaving them to sort through policy language alone.

Buscando Seguro, Orlando#8
Strong points
  • Spanish-language multi-carrier comparisons

  • ITIN and foreign-license support

Buscando Seguro

4.9250 reviews
13550 Village Park Dr Ste 315, Orlando, FL 32837, United States
Ideal for
Spanish-speaking driversITIN or foreign-license holders

Buscando Seguro is an Orlando auto insurance agency built around Spanish-language guidance and comparison shopping. Its service covers auto, home and business insurance, with quotes compared across more than 20 companies and support for customers using an ITIN or foreign driver’s license.

The agency’s value lies in making policy choices easier to understand: staff members explain options, answer questions patiently and offer practical direction during selection or policy issues. Online appointments are available, while on-site service requires an appointment.

Insurance Group Of Central FL, Orlando#9
Strong points
  • Broad personal and commercial coverage

  • Helpful policy explanations

Insurance Group Of Central FL

4.9166 reviews
1155 S Semoran Blvd Ste 1120, Winter Park, FL 32792, United States
Ideal for
Multi-policy householdsFirst-time homeowners

Insurance Group of Central Florida serves Orlando-area customers with auto, home, motorcycle, RV, condo, flood, umbrella, boat, commercial and life insurance. Its independent-agency model is well suited to households and businesses that need several forms of protection reviewed together rather than handled separately.

The team emphasizes patient explanations, responsive service and policy customization around budget and exposure. Online quoting adds convenience, while the agency’s broad product range makes it useful for first-time homeowners, vehicle owners and commercial clients managing more complex coverage needs.

Acceptance Insurance, Orlando#10
Strong points
  • Patient help with difficult coverage cases

Acceptance Insurance

4.8410 reviews
1020 Lee Rd, Orlando, FL 32810, United States
Ideal for
Auto and SR-22 policiesMotorcycle insurance

Acceptance Insurance gives Orlando customers a straightforward place to compare auto, motorcycle, renters, home and SR-22 coverage. Agents focus on explaining policy choices patiently, responding to questions without pressure and helping drivers work through difficult insurance situations that other offices may decline.

The local service is especially useful when affordability matters but coverage details still need careful attention. Bilingual assistance is available, and the team can compare options across carriers while keeping the process organized from quote through policy setup.

Deca Insure, Orlando#11
Strong points
  • Responsive support for personal and business policies

  • Efficient help with urgent questions

Deca Insure

4.8235 reviews
6965 Piazza Grande Ave Ste 407, Orlando, FL 32835, United States
Ideal for
Multi-vehicle householdsSmall-business insurance

Deca Insure provides Orlando insurance support for personal vehicles and business coverage, with a service style centered on responsiveness and practical problem-solving. The team helps customers compare options, understand coverage and work through questions that may otherwise delay a policy decision.

Its appeal is strongest for drivers or small-business owners who want an efficient process without losing access to personal assistance. Staff members are described as quick to respond, attentive to details and able to resolve urgent clarification or documentation needs with a calm, professional approach.

Acceptance Insurance, Orlando#12
Strong points
  • Patient help after premium changes

  • Auto, renters and home coverage

Acceptance Insurance

4.8205 reviews
653 Maguire Blvd STE 850, Orlando, FL 32803, United States
Ideal for
Drivers seeking lower-cost alternativesPolicy reinstatement assistance

Acceptance Insurance in Orlando helps drivers compare auto coverage and related policies through a practical, service-oriented process. Agents work through rate and coverage questions patiently, explain the available choices and help customers who need to reinstate a policy or find a better fit after a premium change.

The office also handles motorcycle, renters and home insurance, with bilingual service available. On-site assistance and parking make the location convenient for customers who prefer to discuss policy details face to face rather than complete the process entirely online.

Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service, Orlando#13
Strong points
  • Insurance and tax services under one roof

Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service

4.7328 reviews
1411 Sand Lake Rd Ste. E, Orlando, FL 32809, United States
Ideal for
Auto insurance and tax preparation

Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service combines Orlando auto and personal insurance with tax preparation for individuals, partnerships, corporations, trusts and other organizations. Its insurance team can compare options across numerous carriers for vehicles, homes, businesses, rental properties, boats and motorcycles, while the tax side adds return preparation and refund-focused assistance.

The office offers online appointments and on-site service, making it a practical destination for customers who prefer to handle related financial tasks in one place. Service can be efficient and helpful, though requesting a clear explanation of the policy or tax steps is especially important when the matter involves a claim or documentation.

Estrella Insurance, Orlando#14
Strong points
  • Responsive SR-22 policy assistance

  • Bilingual quote guidance

Estrella Insurance

4.7296 reviews
8204 Crystal Clear Ln #800, Orlando, FL 32809, United States

Estrella Insurance in Orlando provides auto and home insurance quotes with a focus on affordable coverage and responsive personal service. The team helps customers compare prices, understand policy choices and resolve specific needs such as SR-22 insurance.

Service is organized and efficient, with agents recognized for finding alternatives quickly when a policy or price changes. Bilingual assistance is available, making the office a convenient option for customers who want straightforward guidance in their preferred language.

Estrella Insurance, Orlando#15
Strong points
  • Patient follow-up after policy setup

  • Bilingual personal assistance

Estrella Insurance

4.7288 reviews
174Â, S Semoran Blvd, Orlando, FL 32807, United States
Ideal for
Auto insurance comparisonsRenters coverage

Estrella Insurance in Orlando helps customers compare auto, home and renters coverage through patient, personal guidance. Agents take time to answer questions, explain options and follow up so new policies remain on track after the initial quote.

The office is also useful for customers seeking affordable alternatives or changing an existing policy, with responsive support when rates or coverage needs shift. Bilingual service is available, and the team’s approachable style suits drivers and households that prefer a local conversation over a purely automated quote.

The essentials in one table

#BusinessRatingReviewsIdeal for
#1Univista Insurance 5.02,739Drivers comparing auto coverage
#2Univista Insurance 4.92,281Drivers new to Florida
#3Erb and Young Insurance 4.91,107—
#4White Agency, Inc 5.0136Home and auto bundles
#5GoldenTrust Insurance Central Florida 5.0128Commercial vehicle coverage
#6Direct Auto Insurance 4.9333Drivers comparing coverage options
#7Acceptance Insurance 4.9268Auto and motorcycle coverage
#8Buscando Seguro 4.9250Spanish-speaking drivers
#9Insurance Group Of Central FL 4.9166Multi-policy households
#10Acceptance Insurance 4.8410Auto and SR-22 policies
#11Deca Insure 4.8235Multi-vehicle households
#12Acceptance Insurance 4.8205Drivers seeking lower-cost alternatives
#13Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service 4.7328Auto insurance and tax preparation
#14Estrella Insurance 4.7296—
#15Estrella Insurance 4.7288Auto insurance comparisons

Business owner or manager?

Manage my business profile

Where to find auto insurance brokerages in Orlando

No neighborhood grouping is used here, so the practical map question is coverage and convenience across Orlando. The selection includes agencies serving everyday drivers as well as people new to Florida, motorcycle owners, and commercial customers. A nearby office is useful when documents or policy questions need discussion, while a remote conversation may be more convenient for a simple quote comparison. Confirm service availability and required paperwork before making the trip.

Services on offer

  • Auto coverage comparisonsReview coverage options side by side when you want to understand what each policy includes.
  • New-to-Florida insuranceFind help organizing an auto policy when moving to Florida or adapting to local requirements.
  • SR-22 policiesAsk about policy arrangements involving an SR-22 and the documents needed to begin.
  • Motorcycle insuranceCompare agencies that handle motorcycle coverage alongside or separately from auto insurance.
  • Spanish-language assistanceConnect with an option associated with support for Spanish-speaking drivers.
  • ITIN or foreign-license casesAsk about documentation pathways for drivers using an ITIN or foreign license.
  • Home and auto bundlesExplore combined home and auto coverage when reviewing more than one policy.
  • Commercial vehicle insuranceDiscuss commercial insurance and vehicle coverage for business-related driving needs.

Choosing well among auto insurance brokerages in Orlando

  1. List every driver and vehiclePrepare names, license details, vehicle identification information, annual mileage, and the main use of each vehicle before requesting quotes.
  2. Ask what each limit coversRequest a plain-language explanation of liability, collision, comprehensive, uninsured-motorist, and deductible choices rather than comparing only the premium.
  3. Confirm documentation firstIf you have an ITIN, foreign license, or SR-22 requirement, ask which documents are accepted and when proof of coverage can be issued.
  4. Test bundle assumptionsWhen considering home and auto insurance together, ask whether the policies must be placed with the same carrier and how claims would be handled.
  5. Separate personal and business useExplain deliveries, employees, passengers, or commercial equipment so a personal policy is not compared with the wrong type of vehicle coverage.

Questions readers ask

Can someone new to Florida get help comparing auto insurance?

Yes, some Orlando agencies are associated with drivers who are new to Florida. Bring your current policy, driving history, vehicle details, and identification documents, then ask how prior coverage and licensing history will be considered.

What should I ask about an SR-22 policy?

Confirm whether the agency handles the filing, which insurer would issue the policy, how long the requirement applies, and how a cancellation or vehicle change could affect compliance. Ask for the required documents before beginning the application.

Can I compare motorcycle and car insurance together?

Some agencies handle both auto and motorcycle coverage. Ask whether one carrier can insure both vehicles, whether the protections differ, and whether combining policies changes deductibles, exclusions, or documentation requirements.

Is Spanish-language assistance available?

Buscando Seguro is associated with Spanish-speaking drivers, but confirm the language available for quoting, policy documents, and claims questions. Clear communication matters when discussing exclusions, deductibles, and the exact protection selected.

Keep exploring